Work hard, they said?
On meritocracy, office politics, and a game nobody tells you the rules of
I haven’t been promoted in four years.
There, I said it. For seven years I have worked with one default setting: give at least 100%. Not 80% on a lazy day, not 90% when the project is boring. A hundred, minimum. I grew up believing that if you work hard enough, someone will eventually notice. Hence, I worked hard. And kept working hard. And then, somewhere along the way, I caught myself not wanting to contribute anymore.
Not because I got lazy. I don’t think I’m capable of that tho. It was more like a slow leak. Why should I stay late polishing this deck? Who is actually going to read it? And if they do read it, will it change anything about how I’m seen?
I blamed myself first, it’s my habit. Maybe I’m not good enough. Maybe my work isn’t as sharp as I think it is. Maybe I talk too much in meetings, or too little. But the longer I stayed, the more I noticed a pattern (I can’t help it, recognising patterns is basically my hobby): the people who rise are not always the ones doing the best work. Sometimes they are. Often, they’re the ones who know how to be seen doing it.
So I started asking a bigger question.
Does meritocracy actually happen in Asia? In Indonesia? Or is it just a nice word we put in our HR slides?
I’m not the only tired one
Let’s start with the boring-but-important part. A 2022 regional study of 3,000 employees found that half of the workers surveyed in Indonesia, the Philippines and Singapore feel burnt out at least a few times a month. Half. That’s not a personal problem anymore, that’s a pattern.
Of course, burnout has many causes. Workload is one. Politics is another. But my gut says the real problem sits somewhere in between: in how “merit” itself is defined and measured.
On paper, Indonesia has done everything right. Merit is written into civil service law. There is even a commission (KASN) that scores government institutions on how well they apply the merit system. The results, though? In 2023, only 15.7% of institutions got a “Very Good” rating. And the weakest areas were, guess what, career development (33.5%) and promotion and transfer (51.0%). Precisely the two things someone like me cares about most.
Why? One study points at the design itself: when regional heads are both political officials and the managers of civil servants, merit gets compromised by default. Simply put, the referee is also playing the match.
Now, I work in a state-owned enterprise. And SOEs are a special kind of complicated. We’re supposed to act like a commercial company, yet the government is our owner, which means political influence is always somewhere in the room. The Asian Development Bank noted that interventions stayed frequent even after a dedicated SOE ministry was created. Other researchers have documented rent-seeking, collusion and patronage at leadership level in Indonesian SOEs. I’m not going to comment on my own workplace here (I would like to keep my job, thank you), but here is my working theory: the closer an organisation is tied to the state, the stronger its political game.
And then there’s culture
Indonesia scores 78 on Hofstede’s power distance index. Translation: bosses expect obedience, communication is indirect, and negative feedback stays hidden. Then add bapakism, the Javanese ideal of the leader as a father figure. You don’t argue with your father in front of the whole family, do you? You nod. You say “siap, Pak.” You fix it quietly later.
Researchers call the result organisational silence: people stop voicing concerns because it’s safer not to. And if nobody says what they actually think, how can performance ever be measured objectively? It can’t. At best, it’s incomplete.
So what is being rewarded instead?
Here’s my uncomfortable answer. If hard skills aren’t enough, then something else is doing the work. Soft skills, sure. But more precisely: the ideal attitude. The unwritten set of behaviours that decides who gets seen, who gets heard, and who gets promoted.
I call it the game of attitude.
Is this just bitterness talking? I asked myself that too. Turns out, no. A meta-analysis of influence tactics found that ingratiation (yes, being likeable to your boss) and rationality (making logical, evidence-based arguments) both have positive effects on performance evaluations and promotions. Being good helps. Being liked helps too.
Having said that, almost all this evidence comes from Western, low power distance workplaces. What does the ideal attitude look like in a hierarchical, politically wired place like an Indonesian SOE? Nobody has really measured it.
That bothers me. Like, actually-keeps-me-up-at-night bothers me.
The four moves I keep seeing
I’ve spent years sitting across from C-suite executives, working next to consultants, and juggling stakeholders who all want different things. Along the way I noticed four moves people use to influence decisions from below. And because I can’t switch off the behavioural science part of my brain, each of them has a name.
The decoy. You don’t present one option. You present three, with a sensitivity analysis, and one of them is conveniently worse than the one you want. Suddenly, your preferred option looks obviously right. Behavioural economists call this the decoy effect, and it has been documented since 1982.
Salience. Document your work. Present it well. Make sure your name is on it. People pay disproportionate attention to whatever is most visible and credit it for causing things. In short: you have to be at the centre of attention to get attention.
Framing. When your idea gets rejected, you don’t give up, you re-angle it. Same argument, different wrapping: the one your audience prefers. Tversky and Kahneman showed that logically identical choices produce different decisions depending on how they’re described. And there’s research showing that how middle managers package and “sell” an issue decides whether top management pays attention at all.
Priming. The slow one. You plant an idea through a joke, a passing comment, a “by the way” before the meeting starts. Weeks later, someone brings it up as if it’s theirs. Honestly? I’ll take it. The science on priming is shakier (some famous studies failed to replicate), and in practice it needs patience. A lot of it.
Is this manipulation?
I’ve asked myself this more than once. Maybe it is, if you use it to push something bad. But I see these moves as soft tools for when measured merit isn’t the only ladder available. They sit within the nudge tradition: shaping choices without taking options away. Where influence ends and manipulation begins is honestly part of what I want to find out, not something I’ve settled. And I have no evidence yet that any of this actually works. Just patterns. Just me, noticing.
Why should anyone besides me care?
Because it’s not only about my career. Studies of strategic decision-making show that political behaviour is linked to less effective decisions, and politics inside top management teams is linked to poorer firm performance. Think about it: if promotion rewards conformity over sharp analysis, who ends up at the top? Not necessarily the people who question assumptions.
Thus, a biased meritocracy doesn’t just hurt the people who get overlooked. It makes the whole organisation slowly less sharp. Bad analysis leads to bad decisions. And bad decisions, given enough time, can erode even a healthy company.
So, what now?
I could quit. I could become the loud one who calls everything out. Neither feels realistic, and neither changes the system much. What I actually want to know is what lies within an individual’s control. How do you play the game of attitude well enough to reach your goals, and nudge decisions towards a shared vision, without turning into the disruptive force everyone learns to ignore?
Will I find that meritocracy is a myth? Maybe. Will I find that the game of attitude is just how humans work everywhere, and Indonesia only plays it louder? Also maybe. I don’t know yet. That’s the point of research, I guess.
Ironically, the thing I want to study is the same thing that drained me. Seven years of giving 100% taught me that working hard is necessary, but not sufficient. Somewhere along the way I tied my worth to what I contribute, so when the contribution went unrewarded, it felt like I wasn’t worth much either. I’m working on that part separately.
For now, the goal is not just to survive the system. It’s to understand it well enough to change a little of it, from the inside.
And yes, I’m aware this whole post is one big exercise in framing. I guess that only proves the point.
(P.S: This is a spoiler of what’s my research proposal gonna be)

Comments
Post a Comment
Thank you for visiting my blog, kindly leave your comment below :)
In a moment, I can't reply your comments due to error in my account when replying. But I make sure that I read every single comment you leave here :)